Courts, Boards, & GAO

Trending Now
“Close Enough” Isn’t Good Enough: Protester’s “Homebrew” Certification Sinks Proposal • Lost in Translation: GAO Upholds Rejection of Lease Written in Japanese • Bid Protests in Alaska • Federal Circuit Holds Challengers to CICA Stay Overrides Need Not Satisfy Four-Factor Injunctive Relief Test • The Clock Is Still Ticking — Claims Timeliness Across the Boards and at the COFC

Protester Skipped Filing Comments on the Agency Report and Instead Rested on Its Initial Pleading. It Didn’t Go Well.

GAO dismissed a protest after the protester failed to file comments. The protester requested reconsideration. It claimed that its failure file comments did not mean it had abandoned its protest. Rather, the protester claimed the protest could be decided on the initial protest filing. GAO rejected the argument, reasoning that bid protest regulations require protesters to file comments on the agency's report.

Hawthorne Commercial Construction--Reconsideration, GAO, B-423753.3

  • Background - Hawthorne Commercial Construction filed a protest challenging the evaluation of its proposal. GAO dismissed the protest after the protester failed to file mandatory comments on the agency's report. The protester asked GAO to reconsider.
  • Protester's Argument - The protester argued that dismissal was inappropriate since it did not intend to abandon its protest. It contended that it was not necessary to reiterate arguments from the original filing and claimed that its reliance on its initial protest should suffice.
  • GAO Affirms Dismissal: GAO upheld the dismissal under clear regulations stating that failure to submit comments within 10 calendar days will result in the protest being dismissed. It reiterated that such timelines are essential for the timely resolution of bid protests, emphasizing that the protest's procedural rules are known and must be strictly followed.

The protester is represented by Peter Ianuzzi. The Department of Veterans Affairs, the government, is represented by Natica C. Neely, Esq. GAO attorneys Jungi Hong, Esq., and Peter H. Tran, Esq., participated in the decision.

Get daily insights on bid protests, CDA claims, and contract litigation that shape the GovCon landscape with our Protests & Claims newsletter, delivering up-to-the-minute intelligence Monday–Saturday — Subscribe here.