Courts, Boards, & GAO

Trending Now
Supreme Court Holds that Federal Law Does Not Preempt State Tort Claims When the Contractor’s Own Negligence Causes Injuries • You Can’t Blame the Government for Weather You Could Have Predicted • COFC Holds that USAID Contractors Properly Pleaded Breach of Contract by Improper Mass Termination in Bad Faith/Abuse of Discretion • Bid Protests in Maine • Army Awards $2.7B Contract for Dark Eagle Hypersonic Weapon

Thank You for Your Interest, But We Regret to Inform You . . . GAO Unable to Hear Protest If Erroneously Awarded Contract Cannot Be Terminated for Convenience; Dolphin Park TT, LLC B-419899

Protest challenging award of a lease contract is dismissed. The agency took corrective action agreeing that it had erroneously awarded the contract. But the contract did not contain a termination for convenience. The agency was bound to accept performance from the awardee. The only remedy available to the protester was reimbursement of proposal costs. Because the agency had already offered the only available remedy, there was nothing for GAO to decide.

The General Services Administration awarded a lease contract to Imperium Equity Partners. An unsuccessful offeror, Dolphin Park TT, LLC, protested the award. GSA filed notice that it was going to take corrective action to reimburse Dolphin its proposal preparation costs. GSA noted that the contract did not have termination for convenience clause. As a result, GSA could not terminate the contract and proposal costs were the only remedy available. GSA asked GAO to dismiss the protest.

GAO agreed with GSA. GAO will not consider protests that have no practical consequences where GAO would in essence be issuing an advisory opinion. Here, because the contract did not contain a termination for convenience clause, the agency was bound by the contract and there was little GAO could do other than award proposal costs. GSA had already agreed to perform the full scope of activities that GAO would recommend. There was nothing left to decide.

Dolphin Park is represented by Richard J. Conway and Michael J. Slattery of Blank Rome LLP. The intervenor, Imperium Equity Partners, is represented by Diana Parks and Hadeel N. Masseoud of Curran Legal Services Group, Inc. The agency is represented by Gregory Swartzberg of the General Services Administration. GAO attorneys Glenn G. Wolcott and Christina Sklarew participated in the preparation of the decision.

Get daily insights on bid protests, CDA claims, and contract litigation that shape the GovCon landscape with our Protests & Claims newsletter, delivering up-to-the-minute intelligence Monday–Saturday — Subscribe here.